If your character is good, giving it to Azura may be the right choice so humanity can never possess such a powerful artifact. I always get the black star because I never get companions on any of my character. Answer: Objectively, The Black Star is better than Azuras Star. However I find the Black Star more useful, since every simple bandit, foresworn or whatnot has a grand soul that fills the Black Star fully with tasty soul energy. Given that its the location of Azuras Star, this means you cant just head there directly before speaking to Aranea of Nelacar. I'd get 20-30 grand gems in one rotation. The loot inside the chests will be random, but there are some decent static goodies lying around the place. If you bring the star to Azura, she will name you her champion, reward you with Azura's Star, and you will be able to recruit Aranea Ienith as a companion. Should I give star to aranea or Nelacar? The most precious of them is of course the Broken Azura's Star, lying in front of the throne (screen above). Be careful if visiting the shrine from the west. If you bring it to Azura, you will be able to use it to trap any sized soul except for black souls (i.e., souls from NPCs).If you bring it to Nelacar, you will be able to trap all souls, including black, though Nelacar tells you that it can only trap black souls (see bugs section). Who do I bring the black star to? Upon Malyn's defeat, Nelacar will pull the Dragonborn out of the star and gift the newly made Black Star as a reward. For other uses, see Azura's Star. Azura's Star. Nelacar is an Altmer sorcerer and former member of the College of Winterhold, currently living in the Frozen Hearth inn in Winterhold.He was asked to leave the college due to some failed experiments. Bringing The Star To Aranea Or Nelacar The Black Star quest in Skyrim will require you to go a bit out of your way to find the Shrine of Azura. He can be found at The Frozen Hearth where he runs a small shop. 2) Aela the Huntress. I don't like the idea of helping a man sympathetic to a wizard who would use his own students' lives to try and achieve immortality. Which Teeth Are Normally Considered Anodontia? There are a few flooded sections with locked chests underwater, as well as some valuable loot like a Breathing Water Arcane Tome. First Option: Bring the Star to Aranea If you choose to bring the Star to Aranea, go back to the Shrine of Azura. It can store a trapped soul, like any other Soul Gem, but it doesnt break when you enchant or refill a weapon with it. The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim Special Edition. Dagur: "I see. After acquiring the broken Azuras Star, the Dragonborn can bring it to either Aranea Ienith or Nelacar, both of whom will task them with evicting Malyn Varens soul from the artifact. Who is the most powerful follower in Skyrim? A limit involving the quotient of two sums, ERROR: CREATE MATERIALIZED VIEW WITH DATA cannot be executed from a function, What does this means in this context? I went with Aranea once because admittedly she is awesome, but then she drove an Ice Spike through me once, killing me. The game has loads of soul gems, no problems recharging anything ever. From this point on, Nelacar becomes a spell tomes merchant. Dialogue Destroy Malyn Varen's soul. Dagur: "No, I certainly didn't! Function. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. But she is a daedra. Azura's Star or The Black Star? Hell be wandering around the Frozen Hearth Inn, inside the town of Winterhold rather than the college. Once you get him to open up, Nelcar will tell you that his former master, Malyn Varen, was experimenting with Azuras Star. This nods to his involvement with Malyn Varen's unlawful research into Soul Gems and Azura's Star. I have yet to capture any. What is the best thing to do with Azuras Star? Pissing off Azura seems like a bad idea RP wise. Nelacar, the Altmer mage in Winterhold, can now become a Follower or be Married. What is the best thing to do with Azuras Star? If you're evil then taking it to Nelecar and gaining the Human Soul Devouring, Black Star, may be more appropriate. Then, in the enchantment menu, you can use it to either enchant a new piece of gear or refill a currently enchanted weapon. The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim Achievements. People are prone to dying. If you bring it to Azura, you will be able to use it to trap any sized soul except for black souls (i.e., souls from NPCs). Nelacar has severed all ties with the College, but you can placate him with a good Speech check or bribe him. How do I align things in the following tabular environment? Azuras Star is a powerful Daedric Artifact, similar to a Soul Gem, but unique in that it is reusable. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it. Valve Corporation. I go with Aranea, more to please Azura than anything else. However, I do not know which one is the good and which is the bad ending for the quest. How can I find out which sectors are used by files on NTFS? Word on the street is, the Black Star is glitched and will accept any. Speak to Nelacar. In Oblivion, with the white-only Azura's Star I'd just conjure a Xivilai and whack him with . So unless you really want that follower, I'd suggest going for the Black Star. It only takes a minute to sign up. Personally, I wouldn't give it back, the other daedric princes are pretty honest about themselves, Azura likes to think she's kinder or more benevolent than she actually is. Black star = Reusable black soul gem. After acquiring the broken Azura's Star, the Dragonborn can bring it to either Aranea Ienith or Nelacar, both of whom will task them with evicting Malyn Varen's soul from the artifact. So, thats exactly where youre going. He will be accompanied by three Dremora during the fight. Interestingly, if one goes for The Black Star then we dont get the option to have Aranea Ienith as a follower. oh, what was the name of that quest-related weightless sword with soul trap? Black Souls are always Grand-level, making them incredibly powerful and much more abundant than White Grand Souls. Its still an incredibly valuable item, though, and one that you should definitely search out during your playthrough. Note: This is ONLY to be used to report spam, advertising, and problematic (harassment, fighting, or rude) posts. Needless to say, this is incredibly powerful. The Black Star is Better as Black/Human Souls are More Powerful than Normal White Souls Such as Animals etc.. Should you decide to bring the star back to Nelacar, he'll mention that he may be able to finish Malyn's work and make it so the star only accepts black souls. The Black star is the most useful of the two given how many bandits we have in this game, but later on Soul gems start dropping like rain so its not really needed. Is there a reason you're asking me?" EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Limited Or Anthology Series, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Lead Actress In A Comedy Series, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Supporting Actor In A Comedy Series, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Lead Actress In A Limited Or Anthology Series Or Movie, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Lead Actor In A Limited Or Anthology Series Or Movie. You can either bring the Broken Star back to Nelacar in the Frozen Hearth Inn or to Aranea at the Shine of Azura. It is highly recommended that you do not give this artifact to Martin for the Blood of the Daedra quest. Like regular soul gems, Azuras Star has the ability to trap white souls, or those of creatures. It's been a long while since I started this quest so I remember nothing about the 2 choices. Ilinaltas Deep is broken into two sections. While Azuras Star can only capture White Grand Souls, The Black Star can trap Black Souls. If you give it to Aranea, she can become a follower. Sizin Kredi Notunuz Ka?Danmanmz raporunuzu incelesin ve notunuzu ykseltsin. Azura's star = Reusable grand soul gem. I'm going to pull your soul out of there. Depends on the character. If the Dragonborn brings Azuras Star to Aranea, however, Nelacar stops offering merchant services and instead berates them for serving Azura if spoken to. Can you marry Nelacar in Skyrim? Press J to jump to the feed. Black Star always. All black souls are of the grand level. Shes pretty competent in combat, so that might be a deal-maker for you. In comparison, you can get the same soul from bandits, sneak killing guards, or killing sprees. She can be found at the Shrine of Azura, on top of the tallest mountain slightly south of Winterhold, and becomes available for marriage / follower when you complete Azuras quest. We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. It's a site that collects all the most frequently asked questions and answers, so you don't have to spend hours on searching anywhere else. Its very easy to get overwhelmed here, so dont be afraid to try multiple different approaches. Go to the Shrine of Azura. At the bright young age of nine years old, Eoin played his first-ever video game. Bringing it to Aranea Ienith makes it Azura's Star that can This means that you can end up trapping a pretty mediocre soul in it if youre not careful. Speak with Nelacar. How can we prove that the supernatural or paranormal doesn't exist? You can find the dungeon in the big lake South of Whiterun and North of Falkreath. Nelacar, the Altmer mage in Winterhold, can now become a Follower or be Married. Neither of them are necessarily good or bad. To get this quest, you need to travel to a crc stronghold named Largashbur. What happens if I bring Azura's Star to Nelacar? Why can I fill my black star by soul trapping a mammoth? 444 Video If you bring it to Azura, you will be able to use it to trap any sized soul except for black souls (i.e., souls from NPCs). Hell also tell you that the last location of both Malyn and the star is Ilinaltas Deep. Cheap Flight Tickets%80 SALE! 1) Equip Soul trap 2) Cast it on a mammoth 3) Kill mammoth within 30 seconds 4) Do so every time you need to refill the star. [1] 3 Talk to Aranea Ienith. it The Black Star that can only capture black souls i.e human souls While giving the Star to Nelacar does not provide a companion option, the Black Star has the advantage of a much more abundant source of grand souls, as all black souls are of the grand level. This is because of a bug where the game checks Nelacars Speech skill rather than the players. Objectively, its a worse variant of the star in all conceivable metrics. If you retrieve Broken Azura's Star before starting the quest, you can give it to Nelacar but not Aranea Ienith. I've already corrected it for future experiments." Azura, and is one possible reward for the quest \. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Upon returning with the Broken Azura's Star: "Stendarr's Mercy. If you retrieve Broken Azuras Star before starting the quest, you can give it to Nelacar but not Aranea Ienith. What is the difference between the black star and Azuras Star? Arqade is a question and answer site for passionate videogamers on all platforms. Azura's Star was just an extra grand soul gem. Unlike regular Soul Gems, however, Azuras Star will not break after use, allowing you to refill it. Take it to Nelecar or whatever his name is. He will ask you to bring him Azura's Star, a powerful soul gem which will not be destroyed upon usage and can be refilled an unlimited amount of times. The quest tied to Azuras Star is called The Black Star. Best answer If you return to Aranea, you get Azura's Star which is like a permanent grand soul gem and you get Aranea as a follower if you return star to Nelacar, you get the Black Star which can trap black souls I would say, if you are into enchanting then go with Nelacar, otherwise go with Aranea for more info, see here: Once you finish the quest with him, youll get the Broken Star back as The Black Star. Do I bring Azura's Star to aranea or Nelacar? There is a loose timeline of the stars owners, but it does not appear in any major historical capacity in Tamriel. The Black Star traps any soul. Otherwise, youll have to take your time, picking off each of the Churls one by one. I always pick the black star. Although there are 18 Daedric artifacts in the game, four are technically mutually exclusive (The Ring of Hircine/Saviors Hide, and Azuras Star/The Black Star), and one does not count towards the achievement (The Skeleton Key). The shrine is just South of Winterhold, so you shouldnt have any trouble finding it. The Black Star: Nelacar or Aranea? I always surrender the Masque of Clavicus Vil. What sort of strategies would a medieval military use against a fantasy giant? 1 Answer. After hearing his story, you will need to seek out Maylyne in Ilinaltas Deep, southwest of Whiterun. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. They are directly associated with some of the darkest divine powers - the God of Worms and the Ideal Masters, I try to be as good as I can be, but that's mainly because I find the sneak mechanic kind of odd compared to other games, so I don't fully trust the sneak system to get me in and out of a random house without getting caught, but for the most part I'm a good guy, but I'm far from a Daedra worshipper. It cannot hold Non-Player Character (NPC) souls; Black Soul Gems are necessary for that. Slightly harder to get Grand souls this way. The difference is the Stars use afterwards. I always side with Azura, even though I don't use followers. The gold and intimidation options are not affected. In comparison, to fill Azura's Star one doesnt need to go looking for humans to kill, also morally good, as there are all kinds of creatures available to slay specially during fights. Plus, the Deep is home to a ton of Soul Gems. It can only be visited during the Daedric quest The Black Star.. He resides within The Frozen Hearth inn. Nelacar is a former instructor at the College of Winterhold. Next to the Grimoire will be the Broken Azura Star. In the long run, I would choose the black star - soul gems become so common in the later game in comparison to black ones (I have found 2 black ones, and 60+ others). Inside, youre going to have to fight a bunch of Conjurers and Necromancers. What is the best thing to do with Azura's Star. Ya, a very missed opportunity imo, screw with a prince but no repercussions. Is it suspicious or odd to stand by the gate of a GA airport watching the planes? Recovering from a blunder I made while emailing a professor, Acidity of alcohols and basicity of amines. Bring the Star to Aranea. In Oblivion the Black Soul Gems are the Equivenent of the Black Azuras Star and therefore Hold Human Souls. Nelacar ending 6:25 This is the second part of the mission after getting the gem, both endings here i personally think that turning it into an endless black . Aranea will send you off to Winterhold in search of an elven mage capable of working on Azuras Star, which as of right now isnt in any working state. But if you're like me and you go solo all the time (companions are like babysitting) then take the black star. For the Black Star, a refillable black soul gem, take the star to Nelacar, where he will place the Dragonborn inside the star where Malyn will have to be defeated. After recovering the star, he can transform the Broken Azura's Star into The Black Star, an unlimited Black Soul Gem. If you give it to Aranea , she can become a follower. If it's about rewards--returning to Aranea will give you an infinitely durable grand soul gem, while giving it to Nelacar will give you an infinitely durable black soul gem. ", Nelacar: "I say, you didn't hear any loud noises last night, did you? If you bring it to Nelacar, you will be able to trap all souls, including black, though Nelacar tells you that it can only trap black souls (see bugs section, FormID. I've personally found plenty of grand and black soul gems, so I don't need either of those. Id never sleep with anyone besides my good wife, Drifa . You must pass an average-level Speech check to persuade him. If youre not prepared for this quest, the enemies will kill you in literally seconds, from range. Find Azura's Star. However, its counterpart The Black Star is capable of trapping Black Souls, while Azuras Star cannot. If the story played out the same either way, there would be no reason to pick Azura's Star. Where as Grand soul gems are easier to find but very hard to fill with 'grand souls'. It does have some rules attached to it that you need to be aware of, though. Find the elven mage from Aranea's vision. While giving the Star to Nelacar does not provide a companion option, the Black Star has the advantage of a much more abundant source of grand souls, as all black souls are of the grand level. Rp-wise, it's a lot of trust to put in a shady mage whose first conversation you overhear is about a "miscalculation." ( A girl said this after she killed a demon and saved MC). Azuras Stars big selling point is that it acts as a reusable Grand Soul Gem. [duplicate]. Should I bring Azura's Star to Nelacar or aranea? Whereas white souls usually come in smaller sizes: most random encounters are petty or small souls. Given that Azuras Star can only trap White Grand Souls, that means youre limited to creatures like Mammoths for your high-level souls. Azuras Star isnt capable of capturing Black Souls, instead relying on regular Grand Souls. He was asked to leave the college due to some failed experiments. During your earlier conversation with Nelacar, he will have told you about how all the Daedra are evil and how Azuras Star drove Malyn insane. I included a complete walkthrough of The Black Star earlier in this Azuras Star guide. Azura's Star is a Daedric artifact of the Daedric Prince Azura, and is one possible reward for the quest "The Black Star." . If you bring the Broken Star back to Aranea at the Shine of Azura, youll be presented with Azuras Star at the end of the quest. Unrivaled Mac notes apps for fuss-free note-taking, 6 Actionable Tips for Improving Your Websites SEO, Copyright 2023 | WordPress Theme by MH Themes. So, if you dont mind not being Azuras Champion, then Nelacar is the better option. Should I bring the star to Nelacar or Azura? He gives me privacy, and I make sure my experiments don't blow up his inn.". Instead, bringing it to Nelacar makes Black Star lets you capture Human and Elf souls and can be used more than once. Well, The Black Star is capable of trapping an infinite amount of Black Souls, which are found in Humans, Elves and Orcs, but nowhere else.